Update: Well, I ended up ripping off the old fabric and giving this project another try. I used some old silver flats I had. I loved the green fabric used for the Make It-Love shoes, so I picked some up at Hobby Lobby- 30% off! And, waddya know...I DID IT! :)
Want to give it a shot?
Things you'll need:
Regular and Outdoor Mod Podge
Pair of old flats (or cheap flats you can usually find on clearance for $2 or so)
Fabric large enough to cover both shoes with some excess
hot glue gun/glue
Click on here for the tutorial for mod podge shoes at the Make It and Love It blog.
Have fun! Send me pictures of your creations!